Development of a mathematical model of a chiral metamaterial based on a cylindrical helical elements accounting for the dispersion and concentration of elements
- Authors: Buchnev I.Y.1, Klyuev D.S.1, Mamoshina Y.S.1, Osipov O.V.1, Panin D.N.1
-
Affiliations:
- Povolzhskiy State University of Telecommunications and Informatics
- Issue: Vol 26, No 2 (2023)
- Pages: 36-47
- Section: Articles
- URL: https://journals.ssau.ru/pwp/article/view/23315
- DOI: https://doi.org/10.18469/1810-3189.2023.26.2.36-47
- ID: 23315
Cite item
Abstract
Background. Interest in the study of microwave metamaterials is associated with the possibility of using them to achieve the required frequency and polarization selective properties of interaction with electromagnetic radiation, which can’t be obtained for structures based on homogeneous media. Aim. The mathematical model of a chiral metamaterial based on a periodic matrix of arbitrarily oriented conducting thin-wire cylindrical helices located in a homogeneous isotropic container creation is considered. Unlike known models, it takes into account the explicit form of the dependence of the effective permittivity and the relative chirality parameter on the helices concentration. Methods. The heterogeneity of a chiral metamaterial based on the Maxwell Garnett formula, which makes it possible to determine the effective dielectric permittivity from the permeabilities of the container and the region occupied by conducting mirror asymmetric inclusions is taken into account when creating a mathematical model. The dispersion of permittivity using the quadratic Lorentz formula and the dispersion of the chirality parameter based on the Condon model are taken into account. Results. Analytical frequency-dependent expressions for the effective permittivity and the chirality parameter taking into account the concentration of helices and their geometric parameters, were obtained in the work. The expression for the relationship between the dimensionless volume concentration of inclusions and the distance between adjacent elements is obtained. The quasi-static approach is used to calculate the resonant frequency of conducting thin-wire cylindrical helices. Conclusion. The proposed method for constructing a mathematical model can be applied to chiral metamaterials based on periodic matrices of conductive elements of an arbitrary mirror asymmetric spatial configuration
Full Text
Introduction
Currently, a huge variety of materials, such as polymers, composites, ceramics, alloys, and ferromagnets, have natural, inherent properties of interaction with an electromagnetic field. However, their natural properties can be changed by modifying their spatial structures. In most cases, changes in their electromagnetic properties are related to the addition of various types of composites. One type of composite material is the so-called metamaterial [1–8]. Metamaterials have been actively studied at the beginning of the 21st century. The greatest interest in their study arose after a series of publications [9–11] on the possibility of obtaining negative values of their refractive index, dielectric, and magnetic permeability, although such possibilities have been known for a long time [12]. Such metamaterials are called left-handed media.
Any metamaterial in the microwave range is a combination of a certain medium, called a container, and a certain set of composites of a material with other electrophysical and geometric parameters. Because of their nonstandard properties of interaction with the electromagnetic field, metamaterials are extensively employed in the development of devices such as antennas [13–17], absorbers [18–19], and microwave energy concentrators [20–21].
One of the important types of metamaterials is artificial chiral materials (environment). Such environments have been studied since the 1980s [22–27]. To produce a chiral environment, conductive composites with a mirror-like asymmetric spatial configuration are used. For a chiral (mutual biisotropic) medium, all mirror asymmetric composites are uniformly placed and randomly oriented in a homogeneous container medium. For an equal orientation of all composites, the environment is called bianisotropic. Chiral environments are, in a way, microwave analogs of optically active media and allow rotation of the plane of polarization of an electromagnetic wave by significant angles in the centimeter and millimeter wavelength ranges [28]. Several elements with various spatial structures are employed as conductive mirror composites, such as Tellegen elements [29], cylindrical single- and multistart thin-wire spirals [30], S-elements [31–33], and gammadions [34]. To describe the properties of a chiral medium, the relative chirality parameter is introduced. The main properties of electromagnetic radiation in a chiral medium are the propagation of waves with right-handed and left-handed circular polarizations, as well as the cross-polarization of the incident wave. Consequently, the phenomena of rotation of the plane of polarization and circular dichroism occur.
Questions regarding the mathematical model of a chiral medium have been emerging. The model is based on material equations, which are written in different forms [22–24]. At the beginning of studies on the electromagnetic properties of a chiral medium, its material parameters were considered constant, independent of frequency. Then, researchers have selected different dispersion models for the dielectric permeability and chirality parameters [35–36]. The Lorentz model was used for the dielectric permeability, and the Condon model was used for the chirality parameter, by analogy with an optically active medium. Using dispersion models for magnetic permeability is also known in the scientific literature [36].
Meanwhile, the chiral medium is two-component; that is, it exhibits heterogeneous properties. For the first time, to describe the property of heterogeneity, A.H. Sihvola applied the Maxwell Garnett model [37] on all three material parameters of the chiral medium. In addition, in [37], a dispersion model of a chiral medium was proposed based on the Condon equation. In [38], the Maxwell Garnett model was also used to consider heterogeneity.
In references [39; 40], variants of a mathematical model of a chiral medium were proposed, which simultaneously consider the dispersion of material parameters and heterogeneity. Particularly, it has been shown that at low concentrations of mirror asymmetric inclusions, two-component Maxwell Garnett [41; 42] or Bruggeman [41; 43] models can be used to consider medium heterogeneity.
It is worth noting that in most cases, dispersion and heterogeneous models are used to a sufficient extent independently of each other. Particularly, it is imperative to unify the dependence of material parameters on the concentration of specularly asymmetric inclusions of various types. First, in dielectric permeability, dispersion should not only be considered in the container medium but only in the regions where conductive inclusions are located. Second, it is necessary to use the dimensionless volume concentration of trace elements (included in the Maxwell Garnett and Bruggeman models) both in relation to dielectric permeability and the chirality parameter of the metamaterial.
This work aims to develop a mathematical model of a chiral metamaterial based on a periodic matrix of arbitrarily oriented conducting thin-wire cylindrical spiral elements located in a homogeneous isotropic container medium. The developed model of a chiral metamaterial simultaneously considers the dependence of the effective dielectric permeability and the chirality parameter on frequency and on the concentration of spiral microinclusions. Meanwhile, the possibility of some unification of the indicated dependencies for different types of mirror asymmetric inclusions is demonstrated.
1. Statement of the problem
Let us consider a chiral metamaterial (CMM), which is a uniform matrix of thin-wire conductive single-start spiral elements located in a uniform dielectric container with a relative dielectric permeability Assume that the spiral elements are wound around cylinders with a relative dielectric permeability and their height is equal to the height of the CMM h. The metamaterial has geometric dimensions along three coordinate axes and h. The period of a matrix of spiral elements is determined by the radius of the spiral turn (cylinder) R and the distance between the centers of the cylinders When describing the problem, it is assumed that the periods along the Ox and Oy axes are equal.
The dimensionless concentration of the spiral elements is determined as follows:
(1)
where N is the total number of spiral elements in the metamaterial, V is the volume of the metamaterial (volume of a parallelepiped and V1 is the volume of a three-dimensional figure into which the chiral element is inscribed (for spirals, the volume of a cylinder
The number of spiral elements is determined by the spatial period of the element matrix and the linear dimensions of the CMM container.
The problem geometry is illustrated in Fig. 1.
Fig. 1. Geometry of the metamaterial
Рис. 1. Геометрия метаматериала
2. Relationship between the concentration of chiral elements and their distance
In stage 1 of building a mathematical model, it is necessary to relate the dimensionless concentration of spiral elements to the distance between neighboring elements d.
Let us call the unit cell of the CMM the region containing one helix and the gap to the adjacent helical element. The spatial period of the unit cell is
The number of elementary cells along the Ox axis is determined using
(2)
The number of elementary cells along the axis Oy is determined using
(3)
The total number of unit cells is given by
(4)
where S is the surface area of the metamaterial.
From Eq. (1), we obtain
(5)
where
Finally, from Eq. (5), we obtain
(6)
From Eq. (6), we obtain a quadratic equation regarding the distance between the spiral elements d:
(7)
The solution to Eq. (7) takes the form
(8)
From Eq. (8), the inverse equation is obtained
(9)
From Eq. (9), a generalization of the dependence to the case of arbitrary chiral elements follows
(10)
that is, the dimensionless concentration of chiral elements in the CMM is equal to the ratio of the area occupied by the chiral element to the square of the period of the spatial cell.
Figure 2 presents the dependence for various values of the radius of the spiral turn.
Fig. 2. Dependence at different values of the radius of the spiral turn
Рис. 2. Зависимость при различных значениях радиуса витка спирали
3. Dispersion model of the chirality parameter
To describe the frequency dependence of the chirality parameter, the generalized Condon model is used [1]
(11)
where is the resonant frequency of the chiral element (determined from a quasistatic model for a specific type of element), is the damping frequency, and is the “strength” of the resonance of the chirality parameter.
4. Calculation of the resonant frequency of the spiral element
The mirror asymmetric element is a thin-wire conductive single-start spiral that consists of N turns of radius R located at a distance s (helical pitch). Let us denote l as the length of the spiral in the unfolded state and r as the radius of the thin-wire. Figure 3 exhibits a cross-section of a spiral element. In Fig. 3, the following parameters are introduced: h is the container height, s is the distance between the turns of the spiral, R is the internal radius of the spiral, r is the wire radius, is the spiral winding angle, and N is the number of spiral turns.
Fig. 3. Cross section of the spiral element
Рис. 3. Поперечное сечение спирального элемента
To calculate the resonant frequency of the spiral, a quasistatic approximation was used, and the calculation was performed using Thomson’s equation:
(12)
where L is the inductance of the spiral and C is the spiral capacitance, considering the interturn and interelement capacitances, as well as the capacitance of the conductor (wire) itself.
The method for calculating the resonant frequency of a spiral element is given in [15].
The resonant frequency of the spiral is presented in Fig. 3 and is calculated using
(13)
where is the speed of the electromagnetic wave in vacuum.
Substituting into Eq. (13) the equation for the distance between elements through the concentration of Eq. (8), an equation for the resonant frequency of the spiral element is obtained in the following form:
(14)
Using Eqs. (11) and (14), a dispersion model of the chirality parameter is obtained
(15)
5. Considering metamaterial heterogeneity
We consider the heterogeneity according to Maxwell Garnett’s law [2]:
(16)
where is the relative effective dielectric permeability of the metamaterial (as a spatial structure that consists of a container and components), is the relative dielectric permeability of the container, is the relative dielectric permeability of the region occupied by the component, and is the volumetric dimensionless concentration of the components.
6. Dispersion model of the dielectric permeability
To describe the frequency dependence of the dielectric permeability of the region occupied by a chiral element, we use the Lorentz model [1]:
(17)
where is the resonant frequency of the chiral element (determined from a quasistatic model for a specific type of element), is the damping frequency, and is the “strength” of the dielectric permeability resonance.
Substituting Eq. (17) into Eq. (16), we obtain a dispersion model of the CMM dielectric permeability considering heterogeneity:
(18)
7. Material parameters of a CMM based on thin-wire single-start spiral elements, considering dispersion and heterogeneity
To describe the CMM, we use the following set of material parameters determined from Eqs. (15), (16), and (18):
(19)
8. Material equations for a CMM based on thin-wire single-start spiral elements, considering dispersion and heterogeneity
The material equations for a chiral medium have the form [3]:
(20)
where is the relative effective dielectric permeability, μ is the relative magnetic permeability, and is the relative chirality parameter of the metamaterial.
The material equations (20) are frequency-dependent, and the material parameters of the CMM depend on the volumetric dimensionless concentration of chiral microelements
(21)
where
(22)
The mathematical model defined by Eqs. (21) and (22) describes a CMM produced on the basis of uniformly placed thin-wire conductive single-start spiral elements (Fig. 1).
9. Dispersion equations for normal waves of a CMM based on thin-wire single-start spiral elements that consider dispersion and heterogeneity
The dispersion characteristics (propagation constants) of normal waves of a CMM with right-handed and left-handed circular polarizations are calculated using the following equations:
(23)
where
10. Generalization of the CMM model while simultaneously considering dispersion and heterogeneity
Let us present the capacitance coefficient in the form
(24)
The equation for resonant frequency as a function of dimensionless volume concentration can be summarized as follows:
(25)
where is the phase velocity of the electromagnetic wave in the container medium, coefficients have the dimension of the square of the length and are determined by the geometric dimensions of the chiral elements and their type, and is a dimensionless constant.
Using Eq. (25), we obtain a generalized dependence of the relative chirality parameter on the dimensionless volume concentration:
(26)
Similarly, using Eq. (26), we obtain a generalized dependence of the effective dielectric permeability on the dimensionless volume concentration:
(27)
Eqs. (26) and (27) describe the generalized dependence of the material parameters of a CMM on the frequency and dimensionless volume concentration of chiral elements
Conclusion
We discuss the principles of building a mathematical model of a CMM based on a periodic matrix of arbitrarily oriented conducting thin-wire cylindrical spiral elements located in a homogeneous isotropic container medium.
Our proposed mathematical model of a CMM based on a periodic matrix of arbitrarily oriented conducting thin-wire cylindrical spiral elements considers the heterogeneity of the CMM, the dispersion of the dielectric permeability, the dispersion of the chirality parameter, and the dependence of material parameters on the concentration of spiral inclusions.
Our proposed method for constructing a mathematical model can be applied to CMMs based on periodic matrices of conducting elements of arbitrary mirror asymmetric spatial configuration.
About the authors
Ivan Yu. Buchnev
Povolzhskiy State University of Telecommunications and Informatics
Email: v.buchnev@psuti.ru
postgraduate student of the Department of Higher Mathematics
Russian Federation, SamaraDmitriy S. Klyuev
Povolzhskiy State University of Telecommunications and Informatics
Author for correspondence.
Email: klyuevd@yandex.ru
ORCID iD: 0000-0002-9125-7076
Doctor of Physical and Mathematical Sciences, head of the Department of Radioelectronic Systems
Russian Federation, SamaraYuliya S. Mamoshina
Povolzhskiy State University of Telecommunications and Informatics
Email: u.mamoshina@psuti.ru
postgraduate student of the Department of Theoretical Foundations of Radio Engineering and Communications
SamaraOleg V. Osipov
Povolzhskiy State University of Telecommunications and Informatics
Email: o.osipov@psuti.ru
Doctor of Physical and Mathematical Sciences, head of the Department of Higher Mathematics
Russian Federation, SamaraDmitry N. Panin
Povolzhskiy State University of Telecommunications and Informatics
Email: d.panin@psuti.ru
Candidate of Physical and Mathematical Sciences, head of the Department of Theoretical Foundations of Radio Engineering and Communications
SamaraReferences
- F. Capolino, Theory and Phenomena of Metamaterials. Boca Raton: Taylor & Francis – CRC Press, 2009.
- N. Engheta and R. W. Ziolkowski, Metamaterials: Physics and Engineering Explorations. Hoboken: Wiley, 2006.
- A. K. Iyer, A. Alù, and A. Epstein, “Metamaterials and Metasurfaces – Historical Context, Recent Advances, and Future Directions,” IEEE Transactions on Antennas and Propagation, vol. 68, no. 3, pp. 1223‒1231, 2020, doi: https://doi.org/10.1109/TAP.2020.2969732.
- S. N. Kumar et al., “A review on metamaterials for device applications,” Crystals, vol. 11, no. 5, p. 518, 2021, doi: https://doi.org/10.3390/cryst11050518.
- N. I. Zheludev, “A Roadmap for metamaterials,” Opt. Photonics News, vol. 22, no. 3, pp. 30–35, 2011, doi: https://doi.org/10.1364/OPN.22.3.000030.
- N. Papasimakis et al., “Metamaterial analog of electromagnetically induced transparency,” Phys. Rev. Lett., vol. 101, p. 253903, 2008.
- N. I. Zheludev, “The road ahead for metamaterials,” Science, vol. 328, no. 5978, pp. 582–583, 2010, doi: https://doi.org/10.1126/science.1186756.
- I. B. Vendik and O. G. Vendik, “Metamaterials and their application in microwave technology (Review),” Zhurnal tekhnicheskoy fiziki, vol. 83, no. 1, pp. 3‒28, 2013, url: https://journals.ioffe.ru/articles/viewPDF/41403. (In Russ.)
- D. R. Smith et al., “Composite medium with simultaneously negative permeability and permittivity,” Phys. Rev. Lett., vol. 84, no. 18, pp. 4184–4187, 2000, doi: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.84.4184.
- R. A. Shelby, D. R. Smith, and S. Schultz, “Experimental verification of a negative index of refraction,” Science, vol. 292, no. 5514, pp. 77–79, 2001, doi: https://doi.org/10.1126/science.1058847.
- J. Pendry, “A chiral route to negative refraction,” Science, vol. 306, no. 5700, pp. 1353–1355, 2004, doi: https://doi.org/10.1126/science.1104467.
- V. G. Veselago, “The Electrodynamics of substances with simultaneously negative values of ε and μ,” Soviet Physics Uspekhi, vol. 10, no. 4, pp. 509–512, 1968, doi: https://doi.org/10.1070/PU1968v010n04ABEH003699.
- V. I. Slyusar, “Metamaterials in antenna technology: history and basic principles,” Elektronika: NTB, no. 7, pp. 10‒19, 2009, url: https://www.electronics.ru/files/article_pdf/0/article_287_909.pdf. (In Russ.)
- D. M. Pozar, “Microstrip antennas and arrays on chiral substrates,” IEEE Transactions on Antennas and Propagation, vol. 40, no. 10, pp. 1260‒1263, 1992, doi: https://doi.org/10.1109/8.182462.
- A. L. Buzov et al., “Impedance characteristics of a two-element antenna array with a chiral substrate,” Pis’ma v ZhTF, vol. 44, no. 23, pp. 37‒45, 2018, url: https://journals.ssau.ru/pwp/article/view/7078. (In Russ.)
- A. L. Buzov et al., “Prospects for the use of metamaterials in new generation antennas,” Physics of Wave Processes and Radio Systems, vol. 20, no. 3, pp. 15‒20, 2017, url: https://journals.ssau.ru/pwp/article/view/7078. (In Russ.)
- Y. Liu et al., “Investigation of circularly polarized patch antenna with chiral metamaterial,” IEEE Antennas and Wireless Propagation Letters, vol. 12, pp. 1359–1362, 2013, doi: https://doi.org/10.1109/LAWP.2013.2286191.
- D. Schurig et al., “Metamaterial electromagnetic cloak at microwave frequencies,” Science, vol. 314, no. 5801, pp. 977–980, 2006, doi: https://doi.org/10.1126/science.1133628.
- C. Zhang et al., “Tunable electromagnetically induced transparency from a superconducting terahertz metamaterial,” Appl. Phys. Lett., vol. 110, no. 24, p. 241105, 2017, doi: https://doi.org/10.1063/1.4985618.
- M. Bağmancı et al., “Wide band fractal-based perfect energy absorber and power harvester,” International Journal of RF and Microwave Computer-Aided Engineering, vol. 29, no. 7, p. e21597, 2019, doi: https://doi.org/10.1002/mmce.21597.
- O. V. Osipov, V. I. Yurasov, and A. O. Pocheptsov, “Chiral Metamaterial for Frequency Selective Energy Concentration of Microwave Radiation,” Infokommunikacionnye tehnologii, vol. 12, no. 4, pp. 76‒82, 2014. (In Russ.)
- I. V. Lindell et al., Electromagnetic Waves in Chiral and Bi-Isotropic Media. London: Artech House, 1994.
- A. Lakhtakia, V. K. Varadan, and V. V. Varadan, Time-Harmonic Electromagnetic Fields in Chiral Media. Lecture Notes in Physics. Berlin: Springer-Verlag, 1989.
- C. Caloz and A. Sihvola, “Electromagnetic chirality, Part 1: The microscopic perspective [electromagnetic perspectives],” IEEE Antennas and Propagation Magazine, vol. 62, no. 1, pp. 58‒71, 2020, doi: https://doi.org/10.1109/MAP.2019.2955698.
- S. A. Tret’yakov, “Electrodynamics of complex media: chiral, bi-isotropic and some bianisotropic materials,” Radiotekhnika i elektronika, vol. 39, no. 10, pp. 1457‒1470, 1994. (In Russ.)
- B. Z. Katsenelenbaum et al., “Chiral electrodynamic objects,” Uspekhi fizicheskikh nauk, vol. 167, no. 11, pp. 1201‒1212, 1997, doi: https://doi.org/10.3367/UFNr.0167.199711c.1201. (In Russ.)
- A. A. Sochava, C. R. Simovski, and S. A. Tretyakov, “Chiral effects and eigenwaves in bi-anisotropic omega structures,” Advances in Complex Electromagnetic Materials. Dordrecht: Springer, pp. 85–102, 1997.
- S. Y. Polevoy et al., “Resonant features of planar Faraday metamaterial with high structural symmetry,” Eur. Phys. J. Appl. Phys., vol. 61, no. 3, p. 030501, 2013, doi: https://doi.org/10.1051/epjap/2013120320.
- S. A. Tretyakov and F. Mariotte, “Maxwell Garnett modeling of uniaxial chiral composites with bianisotropic inclusions,” Journal of electromagnetic waves and applications, vol. 9, no. 7-8, pp. 1011–1025, 1995, doi: https://doi.org/10.1163/156939395X00695.
- O. V. Osipov, A. M. Plotnikov, and N. R. Salimova, “Using the effect of azimuthal scattering of electromagnetic waves by a metastructure based on Tellogen elements in applied problems of electrodynamics,” Infokommunikacionnye tehnologii, vol. 10, no. 1, pp. 8‒15, 2012. (In Russ.)
- S. L. Prosvirnin, “Polarization transformation upon reflection of waves by a microstrip grating of complex shape elements,” Radiotekhnika i elektronika, vol. 44, no. 6, pp. 681–686, 1999. (In Russ.)
- T. Ts. Vasil’eva and S. L. Prosvirnin, “Diffraction of electromagnetic waves on a flat grating of complex-shaped chiral strip elements,” Physics of Wave Processes and Radio Systems, vol. 1, no. 4, pp. 5–9, 1998. (In Russ.)
- S. L. Prosvirnin, “Analysis of electromagnetic wave scattering by plane periodical array of chiral strip elements,” Proceedings of 7th International Conference on Complex Media «Bianisotropic ’98», pp. 185–188, 1998.
- R. L. Zhao, J. Zhang, and C. M. Soukoulis, “Conjugated gammadion chiral metamaterial with uniaxial optical activity and negative refractive index,” Phys. Rev. B, vol. 83, no. 3, p. 035105, 2011, doi: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevB.83.035105.
- I. V. Semchenko, S. A. Tretyakov, and A. N. Serdyukov, “Research on chiral and bianisotropic media in Byelorussia and Russia in the last ten years,” Progress in Electromagnetics Research, vol. 12, pp. 335‒370, 1996.
- F. R. Prudêncio and M. G. Silveirinha, “Optical isolation of circularly polarized light with a spontaneous magnetoelectric effect,” Phys. Rev. A, vol. 93, no. 4, p. 043846, 2016, doi: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevA.93.043846.
- A. H. Sihvola, “Temporal dispersion in chiral composite materials: A theoretical study,” Journal of electromagnetic waves and applications, vol. 6, no. 7, pp. 1177–1196, 1992, doi: https://doi.org/10.1163/156939392X01705.
- A. Lakhtakia, V. K. Varadan, and V. V. Varadan, “On the Maxwell Garnett model of chiral composites,” Journal of Materials Research, vol. 8, no. 4, pp. 917–922, 1992, doi: https://doi.org/10.1557/JMR.1993.0917.
- M. V. Aralkin, A. N. Dement’ev, and O. V. Osipov, “Mathematical models of chiral metamaterials based on multi-pass conducting elements,” Physics of Wave Processes and Radio Systems, vol. 23, no. 1, pp. 8‒19, 2020, doi: https://doi.org/10.18469/1810-3189.2020.23.1.8-19. (In Russ.)
- M. V. Aralkin, A. N. Dement’ev, and O. V. Osipov, “Investigation of the electromagnetic characteristics of planar chiral metastructures based on compound helical components, taking into account the heterogeneous Bruggeman model,” Physics of Wave Processes and Radio Systems, vol. 23, no. 3, pp. 44‒55, 2020, doi: https://doi.org/10.18469/1810-3189.2020.23.3.44-55. (In Russ.)
- M. Ya. Sushko and S. K. Kris’kiv, “Compact group method in the theory of permittivity of heterogeneous systems,” Zhurnal tekhnicheskoy fiziki, vol. 79, no. 3, pp. 97‒101, 2009, url: https://journals.ioffe.ru/articles/9645. (In Russ.)
- J. C. Garnett, “Maxwell. Colours in metal glasses and in metallic films,” Phylos. Trans. R. Soc. London. Ser. A, vol. 203, pp. 385‒420, 1904.
- D. A. G. Bruggeman, “Berechnung verschiedener physikalischer Konstanten von eterogenen Substanzen, I. Dielektrizitatskonstanten und Leitfahigkeiten der Mischkorper aus isotropen Substanzen,” Ann. Phys., vol. 416, no. 7, pp. 636‒664, 1935, doi: https://doi.org/10.1002/andp.19354160705.